Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza has been open in downtown Middleton for a little while now, and after our first family visit, it has earned a spot on our pizza rotation.
The short version: the pizza is good, the pepperoni rolls are worth ordering, and the menu is a lot more flexible than it looks. If you have a table that can’t agree on toppings, Piesanos makes that easy.
Here is what we tried, what stood out and what we would order next time.
The tip we wish we knew sooner: half-and-half pizzas
This was the biggest thing we learned on our visit. You don’t have to commit the whole pie to one style. You can order a half-and-half pizza with two entirely different pizzas on each side, and you can mix several toppings on one pie. We were told you may even be able to split one pizza four ways, so ask when you order.
That makes Piesanos a smart pick for families and groups. One half can stay plain for the kids while the other half gets loaded up. Or split a large between two specialty styles so everyone gets what they want without ordering two pizzas.
Just ask when you order. The build-your-own pizza starts with a cheese pie, and toppings are priced by size.
The Pepperoni Rolls: great, but not as a starter
The Pepperoni Rolls are stone-baked rolls stuffed with pepperoni and cheese, brushed with garlic butter and Romano and served with marinara. An order comes with four. They were good. But we would not order them before a pizza again.
Here is why: when you dine in, Piesanos already brings out bread rolls soaked in Italian dressing. Add the pepperoni rolls on top of that, then a pizza, and it was way too much food.
Our advice: get the pepperoni rolls instead of a pizza, not before one. Pepperoni rolls and a salad and you are set. That combo is even on the lunch specials menu between 11 a.m. and 4 p.m.
The Mediterranean pizza: a split decision
The Mediterranean pizza comes with fresh spinach, artichoke hearts, tomatoes, Kalamata olives, crumbled feta and mozzarella. My wife liked it a lot. It wasn’t my favorite, but if you like a lighter, veggie-forward pizza with some salty feta and olives, it is worth a try.
Honestly, that was the only thing on the table I wasn’t sold on. I liked nearly everything else we ordered.
Know your pepperoni
Pepperoni fans have options here. Piesanos carries four kinds of pepperoni: sliced, diced, spicy Napoletana and mini cup-and-char, the little cups that crisp up at the edges. A few pizzas lean into that:
- Pepperoni Explosion: sliced and diced pepperoni with double cheese.
- Pizza Antico: ultra-thin crust with fresh mozzarella, cup-and-char pepperoni and fresh basil.
- Napoletana: extra cheese, spicy pepperoni Napoletana and fresh garlic.
We haven’t tried these yet, but they are on our list for next time. Piesanos is also running a limited-time Quadruple Pepperoni Pizza with all four kinds on one pie.
Other menu finds worth knowing
- Sizes for every group: pizzas come in 8-, 12-, 16- and 20-inch sizes, plus a 10-inch cauliflower crust.
- Thin-crust options: the Rustica and Pizza Antico are ultra-thin, old-world style pies.
- Kids menu: cheese or pepperoni pizza, spaghetti and meatball, buttered penne, a meatball sub or chicken fingers.
- Lunch specials (11 a.m.–4 p.m.): including two cheese slices and a soft drink, and a 2-topping personal pie.
- Not just pizza: there are calzones, pastas, subs, salads and desserts like cannoli and tiramisu, plus a full bar.
Our first-order shortlist
- Enjoy the free dressing-soaked bread rolls that come with dine-in. Skip the extra appetizer.
- A large half-and-half pizza with two different pies so everyone gets what they want.
- Put the Mediterranean on one half if your group likes veggie pizzas.
- Not that hungry? Pepperoni rolls and a salad instead of a pizza.
Bottom line
Piesanos is an easy family pizza night in Middleton. Order a half-and-half pizza with two different pies, which is the best trick on the menu. And save the pepperoni rolls for a night when they are the meal, not the warm-up.
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
2259 Dr. Randy McDaniel Way, The Villages, FL 34762
(352) 492-1100
Sunday–Thursday 11 a.m.–9:30 p.m.; Friday–Saturday 11 a.m.–10 p.m.
View the Piesanos menu · Middleton location page
Editor’s note: Menu items, prices and specials can change and may vary by location. Check with Piesanos before you go.
